Blog

Susan and her husband Cliff get flown to New York City for $10,000, a rate she credits to Matt and WPM. Their regular corporate gigs pay $2,500 to $3,000 as a duo.
Plenty of duos can sing and play. So what is the client actually paying for?
Susan answers it in one line:
“The show is the product. If we’re gonna go out and sell any product in any business, you gotta get the product right.”
On this episode, Marty sat down with Susan, an award-winning country artist who, with Cliff, is a two-time Entertainer of the Year at the Arkansas Country Music Awards, to break down what turns a performer into an entertainer, and why that is the part clients pay for.
Marty opened with the line that sets up the whole conversation.
“A lot of live musicians are performers, but not a lot of performers are entertainers.”
Susan’s definition of the difference is simple. It isn’t more talent or a better voice.
“Adding a level of connection with the crowd that would not normally be your first instinct.”
She describes it as breaking down “the invisible wall” between you and the room. Marty put it in terms every musician can check against their own show:
“People love music. We all love music… but that’s one of, like, 20 other things that you can do, and I feel like a lot of people miss that in their toolbox.”
If music is the only tool you bring, you sound like everyone else who brought the same songs.
Susan doesn’t treat entertaining as a gimmick on top of the music. She treats it as a second art form.
“There’s an art to the way you execute a show live.”
That art covers everything: what you say, how you move, the order of the songs, how you engage the crowd, even what you wear. The goal is the reaction every client wants to hear from their guests on the way out:
“Wow, I want to see that show again. That was incredible.”
This is where a lot of musicians get stuck. They hear “entertainer” and picture someone they don’t want to be. Marty named it directly:
“They get nervous that being an entertainer means they have to be cheesy and way over the top, and something that they’re not.”
Susan’s answer is advice someone once gave her:
“Be yourself amplified.”
“We’re all animals and we can tell when something’s real and authentic.”
And if you’re not a natural talker, she has proof it can be learned. Cliff was very introverted, and he came out of his shell on stage by putting in the reps. Nobody needs a new personality. You need a louder version of the one you already have.
Entertaining doesn’t mean forcing a party on every crowd. Susan is clear about that.
“If you’re going to a fine fancy steakhouse and your job is to be ambient and play an instrument in the background, getting the whole room of a steakhouse to sing Sweet Caroline would not be the job description.”
But when the room is there for you, the show is what sets you apart from every other act in town.
“You can absolutely take an opportunity that would typically be somebody just showing up and playing an instrument, to turning it into a show that makes you uniquely different in your market.”
Susan walks in with about 10 songs in mind, and she is intentional about all of it. Even the soundcheck song.
“I don’t do anything that’s going to be my first impression where they’re gonna go, ‘Oh, I don’t like that.’”
Her opening gives the crowd permission to have fun. Then she paces the night in peaks and valleys:
“I’m not giving like five ballads in a row.”
She compares it to a video game. You have all the tools, the crowd is different every night, and the skill is picking the right tool at the right time. Marty had a better analogy:
“There might be 10 kinds of chicken at that buffet, but you’re not gonna eat chicken and then chicken and then chicken and then chicken.”
Once you have enough tools that you aren’t worried about what comes next, you can start taking risks. Some of those risks become what Susan calls magic moments:
“Then it turns into something you’ll do over and over again ‘cause it works so well.”
Marty gave an example. Someone shouts that it’s their birthday. You can let it pass and jump into the next song, or you can make it bigger. Susan showed exactly how she makes it bigger:
“Make some noise if you’re celebrating something tonight.”
She notes the party tables, finds out whose birthday it is, and gets the whole room involved:
“When I say you, shout Lucy.”
She does the same thing with hometowns. “Chicago’s here. New York’s over here.” She doesn’t know their names, so she gives each table one. Her rule underneath all of it:
“If they’re giving you something, go with it. Don’t just shut it down ‘cause you’re too rigid in your plan.”
The flip side of seizing a moment is knowing when to get out. If a song isn’t landing, Susan cuts it short.
“I might do a verse, chorus, verse, chorus and get out.”
Marty tested her with the longest song he could think of, American Pie.
“I’ve never in my entire career done the whole thing.”
Most musicians learn a song start to finish and feel they owe the crowd every verse. Marty pointed out who already knows better:
“DJs know this. DJs, you’re 30 seconds in, it’s not working, flip. You’re out.”
For musicians who want to bring more of this into their own shows, Susan’s set list advice starts with sing-alongs. Have a few known songs ready that raise the room’s energy, like My Girl or Brown Eyed Girl, and make them yours.
“Step outside of your comfort zone and put your artistry on a song that people know and love and naturally wanna sing and clap to.”
She also shared a rule for picking those songs:
“People identify with the songs that they grew up in their formative years with. So if they were listening to that between the ages of 15 and 22, then that’s music you’d wanna play.”
Marty added that the question isn’t just whether a song is fun. It’s what the song does. Brown Eyed Girl gets an older crowd singing even if they stay in their seats. A newer song might be the one that gets a younger crowd out of theirs. He kept a running list of songs he knew would work. He called it the heater list.
This is where the money comes from. Clients aren’t paying $10,000 for a playlist. They are paying for the night their guests talk about after.
“The core differentiating thing is the show and having that great show, ‘cause it’s the product.”
And Susan was clear about where that $10,000 rate came from:
“Matt has helped me tremendously… So I’m doing corporate events and, I mean, we got flown to New York City for $10,000.”
The help she means is on pricing: leaning into getting paid more for the show.
That’s the combination we see over and over. A show worth paying for, and the confidence to charge for it. Marty’s take for anyone who thinks this isn’t for them:
“Even a little bit of learning how to entertain can propel your career in ways that you don’t realize.”
Susan closed the episode with this:
“Half the battle is showing up and putting time into your career… I just really encourage you for doing the work, because that’s where you’re gonna get to the next step.”
Want clients paying for your show, not just your songs? That’s exactly what we do inside Well Paid Musician.